The Washington Post:
WE DON’T expect common-sense gun laws from this Congress, but a couple of House-passed riders to the Justice Department’s 2007 budget are especially noxious — and ripe for Senate repair.
One bars enforcement of a law that requires trigger locks to be sold with all new handguns. The other restricts law enforcement officials’ access to gun-tracking information collected by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF). The Senate Appropriations Committee, scheduled to consider the budget tomorrow, should keep both measures out.
I know of no handgun that I’ve bought in the last several years that did not come with trigger locks. But continuing:
Congress approved the trigger-lock mandate last October. Not only was it a good idea, but it was also part of a broader compromise on the Hill: The Senate added the measure to a bill that limited gunmakers’ legal liability. Yet Rep. Joe Wilson (R-S.C.) argued last month, “Responsible and law-abiding gun owners do not need the government to tell them to be safe.”
The problem is that there are plenty of irresponsible gun owners. Researchers at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported last year that 1.7 million American children live with unlocked, loaded guns in the house. In a study released in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine in May, 39 percent of children knew where their parents kept their guns, and 22 percent claimed that they handled them, even though their parents claimed they didn’t. Studies have indicated that programs such as the National Rifle Association’s Eddie Eagle program, which trains children not to play with their parents’ guns, don’t work.
You guys have a cite for that because I’d love to see it. I looked and couldn’t find any such study. I did find reference to the Journal of Emergency Nursing Online calling it effective and that the National Center for Health Statistics fatal firearms accidents in the Eddie Eagle age group have been reduced more than two thirds since the program’s inception. And that the program has been honored or endorsed by groups such as the National Safety Council, the National Sheriffs’ Association, the Department of Justice, and bipartisan support from 24 state governors. Finally, the mere fact that 24,000 schoolteachers and law enforcement officers have taught the program to 15 million children verifies the popularity of the program with those who deal with child safety issues every day.
Trigger locks won’t save all of the children who, without the law, will die of accidental gunshot wounds (as 151 did in 2003, according to the CDC). Not all gun owners will use them. But locks would make it a lot easier for gun owners to be safe, just as seat belts made it easier for drivers to protect themselves.
Mandating trigger locks is largely pointless. People who are not responsible will not use them even if they come with the gun. Period. More:
But the budget that passed the House last month goes beyond blocking public disclosure; the rider would keep gun-tracing information from local police unless it’s for a specific criminal case. Even then, they couldn’t share it with neighboring authorities — a provision that would seriously hamper tracking and interdiction of illegal guns. If D.C. police used ATF tracing data to find that a large number of guns used in homicides came from one shop in Maryland, District police couldn’t share that information with Maryland law enforcement agents.
And that’s to prevent bogus lawsuits. If there is a specific crime, tracing is still allowed. That is as it should be. Wholesale tracing serves no real purpose that I can determine.
The House also wants to render federal gun-tracing information inadmissible in civil court, hindering legal action against irresponsible gun distributors. New York Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg’s office, which is trying to sue some of these “rogue” gun sellers, claims that civil litigation is an essential tool to fight interstate gun trafficking. Given that in 2000 1.2 percent of gun dealers sold 57 percent of the guns used in crimes, the mayor has a point.
Scare quotes around rogue? That’s because the only person who has broken the law in Bloomberg’s investigations are the City of New York and its agents who illegally purchased weapons from otherwise lawful dealers. There’s been no evidence the dealers broke the law but plenty of evidence to state that NY’s investigators did.