Pretty good suggestion. I use a first year of production 870 with a slug barrel myself. The only time I needed to use it, the guy who broke into my neighbors house soiled his panties and laid down when I cycled the action, but a semi-auto would do just as well.
Anything from a reputable manufacturer that is at least 20 gauge would be very useful in that situation. Even a single shot shotgun would be fairly respectable.
I recommend a shotgun for home defense, but only in the lowest common denominator “yes, you can, Grandma” sense where physical, emotional, or financial barriers exist. A $200 pump action is easily the most accessible defensive tool available.
The Mossberg 930 doesn’t fit that bill at all. Pricey, complicated, it’s a gun-owner’s shotgun. At the $500 price point, a pistol is a better choice all around. The idea that a long gun is best for close quarters is facially absurd — for a novice, a pistol is easier to control when walking through a darkened home.
Call me old-fashioned, but I always fall back on whatever gun you can comfortably, confidently, accurately, and safely load, operate, store and maintain.
Why do people think a sight on a shotgun is necessary? I’ve hunted for years with just the bead on the front and it has worked out well and I don’t see it as a problem for home defense. I have both a pump 12 and 16 ga. for a home defence round.
Why do people think a sight on a shotgun is necessary? I’ve hunted for years with just the bead on the front and it has worked out well and I don’t see it as a problem for home defense. I have both a pump 12 and 16 ga. for a home defence round.
It’s not necessary…so long as you can be sure you’ll be able to mount it to your shoulder exactly the same way every single time.
In a self defense situation, when your adrenalin is flowing, you’re shaking like a leaf, and your fine motor skills are suffering (and hence possibly your mounting as well), a sight can help make sure you’re going to hit what you’re aiming at. Also, a shotgun in a self defense situation is used more like a rifle than a shotgun.
There’s nothing like the sound of a 12 ga. pump being cycled to put the fear of God in an unwanted guest – everyone knows what that distinctive sound means. Sometimes that alone will get the intruder scampering toward the nearest exit.
The Marines found the utility of “rifle type” sights on shotguns effectively by accident.
They stuck ’em there, primarily so teh kids would have a consistant sighting system, instead of having their brains pop out of gear when faced with a gun “you don;t have to use sights with”. (Keep in mind how much KD and bullseye type practice the Marines do with rifles — Classic rifle technique is almost a religion to them.)
What the Green Machine found was that EVERYONE — new Marines to old gunnies, was shooting better, even with the honestly crappy sights they first installed.
Sights help. ESPECIALLY when you aren’t restricting yourself to wing shooting.
February 16th, 2010 at 10:57 am
Pretty good suggestion. I use a first year of production 870 with a slug barrel myself. The only time I needed to use it, the guy who broke into my neighbors house soiled his panties and laid down when I cycled the action, but a semi-auto would do just as well.
Stranger
February 16th, 2010 at 11:08 am
Anything from a reputable manufacturer that is at least 20 gauge would be very useful in that situation. Even a single shot shotgun would be fairly respectable.
February 16th, 2010 at 11:38 am
Yeah, Mossbergs are pretty affordable, and they work. It’s really a pretty good suggestion.
February 16th, 2010 at 1:26 pm
I prefer a pump for reliability reasons. Granted I’m sure that one will eat defensive loads like candy, a 590 offers me a bit more confidence.
February 16th, 2010 at 2:53 pm
I recommend a shotgun for home defense, but only in the lowest common denominator “yes, you can, Grandma” sense where physical, emotional, or financial barriers exist. A $200 pump action is easily the most accessible defensive tool available.
The Mossberg 930 doesn’t fit that bill at all. Pricey, complicated, it’s a gun-owner’s shotgun. At the $500 price point, a pistol is a better choice all around. The idea that a long gun is best for close quarters is facially absurd — for a novice, a pistol is easier to control when walking through a darkened home.
February 16th, 2010 at 3:24 pm
Call me old-fashioned, but I always fall back on whatever gun you can comfortably, confidently, accurately, and safely load, operate, store and maintain.
February 16th, 2010 at 6:04 pm
Why do people think a sight on a shotgun is necessary? I’ve hunted for years with just the bead on the front and it has worked out well and I don’t see it as a problem for home defense. I have both a pump 12 and 16 ga. for a home defence round.
February 16th, 2010 at 7:58 pm
It’s not necessary…so long as you can be sure you’ll be able to mount it to your shoulder exactly the same way every single time.
In a self defense situation, when your adrenalin is flowing, you’re shaking like a leaf, and your fine motor skills are suffering (and hence possibly your mounting as well), a sight can help make sure you’re going to hit what you’re aiming at. Also, a shotgun in a self defense situation is used more like a rifle than a shotgun.
February 17th, 2010 at 12:07 am
There’s nothing like the sound of a 12 ga. pump being cycled to put the fear of God in an unwanted guest – everyone knows what that distinctive sound means. Sometimes that alone will get the intruder scampering toward the nearest exit.
February 17th, 2010 at 6:09 pm
RC —
The Marines found the utility of “rifle type” sights on shotguns effectively by accident.
They stuck ’em there, primarily so teh kids would have a consistant sighting system, instead of having their brains pop out of gear when faced with a gun “you don;t have to use sights with”. (Keep in mind how much KD and bullseye type practice the Marines do with rifles — Classic rifle technique is almost a religion to them.)
What the Green Machine found was that EVERYONE — new Marines to old gunnies, was shooting better, even with the honestly crappy sights they first installed.
Sights help. ESPECIALLY when you aren’t restricting yourself to wing shooting.